Euclid's Influence on Mathematics

My journey into mathematics began with numbers, taught first by my father and later by my elementary teacher. However, 2400 years ago, the educational landscape was quite different, with geometry being prioritized over arithmetic.

In ancient times, particularly before the advent of Christ, geometry was highly regarded. For instance, when Plato established the “Academy” in Athens, he sought to create a hub of intellectual activity. To ensure that only those knowledgeable in geometry entered, he inscribed the phrase “???????????? ?????? ??????” (translated from Greek as “Let no man ignorant of geometry enter”) on the entrance of his institution.

Plato associated his vision of an ideal world with beauty and intellect, both of which are deeply rooted in mathematics. Eventually, a young scholar named Euclid of Alexandria stepped through those doors. He became a mathematician and philosopher, authoring the renowned geometry text, The Elements. This work is considered the most widely recognized mathematics textbook throughout history, only surpassed in print by the Holy Quran and the Bible.

The Elements was revolutionary because it compiled crucial mathematical insights available up to Euclid's time. His groundbreaking ideas formed the foundation of Euclidean geometry and have shaped the teaching of this subject for over two millennia. For a long time, being unacquainted with The Elements was seen as a lack of education. Even in modern times, the text continues to present theories that hold significance today.

Euclid lived around 300 years before Christ and exemplified the dedication needed for mathematical inquiry. Following his passing, his works became a focal point for intellectuals seeking to explore their mental capacities, even if they were not mathematicians.

> For instance, over two millennia later, Abraham Lincoln read Euclid’s Elements by lamplight to refine his reasoning skills during quiet nights at the dormitory. As president, he continued to consult this text to draw logical conclusions for effective governance.

Additionally, the novelist and philosopher Fyodor Dostoyevsky referenced Euclid in his work, The Brothers Karamazov:

> If God exists and indeed created the universe, He must have done so according to the geometry of Euclid. Yet there are geometricians and philosophers who speculate that parallel lines, which Euclid claimed would never meet on Earth, might converge somewhere in infinity. I realize that since I cannot fathom this, I cannot expect to understand divine matters either. I humbly acknowledge my limitations in resolving such profound inquiries with my Euclidean mind.

A century later, the eminent thinker Albert Einstein praised Euclid and his work in his essay On The Method of Theoretical Physics:

> I refer to Euclid’s geometry. This remarkable achievement of reasoning instilled confidence in human intellect for subsequent advancements. If Euclid did not ignite your youthful passion, then perhaps you are not destined to be a scientific thinker.

Bertrand Russell, a prominent philosopher, articulated a succinct evaluation of Euclid:

> Euclid’s Elements is undoubtedly one of the greatest books ever penned and a perfect representation of Greek intellect. In my autobiography, I recount starting Euclid at age eleven, guided by my brother. This was a pivotal moment in my life, as dazzling as first love. I had never anticipated anything could be so delightful.

Euclid remains an enigmatic figure; little is known about his personal life or interests outside of mathematics. Nevertheless, he was a highly regarded educator in Alexandria, focusing on abstract concepts rather than practical construction. He recognized the need for logical reasoning in governance as society evolved, leading to a surge in theoretical mathematics during his time.

He was a thinker unencumbered by mundane issues, discovering truths that modern technology can now verify. Starting with merely a straightedge and a compass, he laid the groundwork for mathematical exploration in The Elements. His initial steps involved drawing two points and a line, which led to a wealth of discoveries. If we consider mathematics an intellectual journey, Euclid’s contributions represent its foundational steps, extending our understanding into the cosmos.

To Euclid, mathematics was vital because it embodies absolute truths, blending the elegance of art with the significance of abstract reasoning. His methodological approach remains a model of logical deduction. He pioneered a way of thinking that transformed mathematics into a discipline grounded in proof, applicable across various contexts.

> When engaging with Euclid’s Elements, you'll observe his unique and straightforward mathematical method. He begins with fundamental assumptions, establishing logical consequences, and concludes with theorems. Crucially, he aimed for universality, providing solutions that transcend specific scenarios.

Exploring Prime Numbers

Let's delve into Euclid's proof concerning prime numbers. While prime numbers may seem unremarkable, their infinite nature is noteworthy. It is widely believed that Euclid was the first to demonstrate the infinitude of primes, marking a significant milestone in mathematical history. Notably, Euclid did not explicitly state, "there are infinitely many primes." Instead, he asserted, “prime numbers are more than any assigned multitude of prime numbers,” reflecting a less developed understanding of infinity than we possess today.

Understanding prime numbers is essential for mathematical comprehension. A prime number is defined as:

Definition: A prime number is a whole number greater than one that is divisible only by one and itself.

The number 1 stands as an exception to this definition. While it meets the criteria for being prime, mathematicians choose not to classify it as such for practical reasons. Including one in the prime category complicates prime factorization, for example:

18 = 2 x 3 x 3 x 1 x 1 x 1 x 1 x 1 x 1 x 1...

This illustrates why one is not considered a prime number.

When Euclid investigated prime numbers, he began by listing the first few primes up to 100. He searched for patterns, a common pursuit in mathematics. For example, he noted that 2 is the only even prime, as all larger even numbers are divisible by 2. Similarly, 3 is prime, but its multiples cannot be prime since they are divisible by 3.

He then posed a significant question: “If I keep writing, will I ever reach an end?” He wished for an infinite supply of prime numbers; otherwise, the future of mathematics seemed bleak. This inquiry was challenging, as he had to examine each number for primality without modern computational tools. Determining whether 13 is prime is straightforward, but checking larger numbers would require an impractical amount of time. Even with the most advanced computers, the search for the largest prime would remain unresolved.

Euclid, using the mathematics of his era, uncovered numerous truths. But to persuade others, he sought absolute certainty, leading to a brilliant proof. He established a theorem:

Theorem: Prime numbers are more than any assigned multitude of prime numbers.

Proving this theorem was crucial to Euclid, so he employed a thought experiment, a method known as proof by contradiction. He envisioned a universe with a finite number of primes, allowing him to create a list. Although the list could be extensive, he labeled the largest prime as “p.” He then proposed to multiply all these primes together and add one.

He didn't know the result, but it was the product of all the primes in his hypothetical universe plus one. He recognized that this number must have a prime factor, given that every number greater than 1 possesses a prime factor.

The Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic: Every integer greater than 1 can be expressed as a product of primes in an essentially unique way.

In other words, primes are the building blocks of all numbers. Educators often liken primes to the "atoms of mathematics."

Next, Euclid wondered if this new prime factor could be 2. The answer was no, as the number would yield a remainder of 1 when divided by 2. The same reasoning applied to other primes, such as 3 and 5, each leaving a remainder of 1. This pattern persisted for all primes on his list.

Euclid's genius lay in constructing a new number that was indivisible by any primes on his list. This new number left a remainder of 1 when divided by all found primes. However, since it must have a prime factor, this led to a contradiction, proving that there must be infinitely many primes.

What Euclid achieved long ago is remarkable; he allowed our finite minds to grasp the concept of infinity through his reasoning. His insights expanded the horizons of knowledge. As previously mentioned, the view from Euclid’s window initiated a revolution that continues to inspire mathematical exploration.

> Note 1: Beyond Euclid! is my weekly newsletter featuring high-quality math and science content to enhance your week. Consider subscribing to Beyond Euclid and supporting my work if you can. Thank you!

> Note 2: I receive commissions for purchases made through links in this post.