Why Do Knuckles Crack? Exploring the Science Behind It
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Knuckle Cracking
Knuckle cracking is a common habit among many, including my adult son, a musician who proudly claims the title of knuckle cracking champion. I’ve witnessed him perform this routine multiple times a day, and it’s quite a sight to behold.
"I do it mostly out of habit," he explained. "But sometimes it’s quite relieving, especially after or during anything that works the hands, like weightlifting or playing an instrument."
While my own knuckle cracking isn’t as impressive or consistent, I find it helps ease my hands during long hours spent typing. According to experts, the sensation of looseness often follows a good cracking session. For some, this act may serve as a nervous tic or a means to release pent-up energy, which could be particularly appealing to children.
The distinct sound we hear when joints crack is linked to gas bubbles forming within the synovial fluid that lubricates our joints. However, the exact mechanics behind the noise are still not entirely understood.
Section 1.1: The Science of the Crack
What we do know is that cracking occurs when the space between joints expands, whether through bending or pulling. This creates a vacuum in the synovial fluid, leading to the formation of air bubbles. The debate remains: does the sound arise from the bubbles forming or collapsing?
Conducting research in 2015, scientists utilized MRI technology to investigate this phenomenon. Their findings suggested that the sound originates from air rushing into a cavity, creating a bubble. In a different approach, a 2017 study proposed that the collapsing of a bubble could explain the sound we hear.
Interestingly, the presence of these air bubbles also clarifies why most individuals can’t crack the same joint twice in quick succession. The air needs time to either build back up or dissolve, depending on which theory holds true. Partial cracks may also happen, enabling a second cracking sooner.
Section 1.2: The Brain's Role in Knuckle Cracking
According to Branden Daubel, a physical therapist at UT Health Austin’s Musculoskeletal Institute, the force generated by these bubbles can stimulate sensory receptors in the joints. This may explain the pleasure some individuals derive from cracking their knuckles, as it sends information to the brain and releases a small amount of dopamine.
Chapter 2: Debunking Myths Surrounding Knuckle Cracking
Contrary to popular belief, particularly what many parents warn, knuckle cracking does not appear to lead to arthritis. A comprehensive study conducted in 1975 found no increased risk of arthritis in habitual knuckle crackers. This conclusion was echoed in a smaller 2011 study.
One of the most intriguing cases is that of Dr. Donald Unger, who conducted a 50-year personal experiment. He cracked the knuckles of only his left hand at least twice daily, totaling over 36,000 instances. His 1998 study revealed no signs of arthritis or significant differences between his hands.
As long as knuckle cracking isn’t painful, there’s no cause for alarm, according to Alexander Soneru, an orthopedic surgeon with Loyola Medicine. He often reassures concerned parents that while the sound may be unpleasant, it is unlikely to have negative long-term effects.
However, some research indicates that frequent knuckle cracking might reduce grip strength. Robert Shmerling, MD, a senior faculty editor at Harvard Health Publishing, suggests that while knuckle cracking is generally harmless, there have been rare reports of dislocations or tendon injuries from excessive cracking.
Mayo Clinic Minute: A Hand Surgeon's Advice on Knuckle Cracking - This video provides insights from a medical professional about the effects and safety of knuckle cracking.
Here's What Happens to Your Knuckles When You Crack Them - A detailed examination of the physical changes in knuckles during the cracking process.
Cracking knuckles may also irritate others, as some people find the sound particularly bothersome. Just ask my son’s father.
Stay tuned with Aha! for more fascinating insights into life’s most captivating, unusual, and unexpected questions. If you’re a writer, consider subscribing to my Writer’s Guide newsletter. Your support is greatly appreciated, as it helps sustain my reporting and writing endeavors. Note: Portions of this article were published previously.