Title: Finding the Right Balance: Show and Tell in Writing
Written on
Chapter 1: The Misconception of "Show, Don't Tell"
As a writer, you've likely encountered the phrase "show, don't tell" countless times. While there is merit to this advice, it isn't entirely foolproof. It emphasizes the contrast between showing and telling, but this binary perspective can be misleading.
The Balance Between Showing and Telling
Showing entails vividly depicting scenes, allowing readers to deduce meanings through sensory details and character actions. On the other hand, telling involves clear exposition and explicit descriptions of events and emotions. Writers face the challenge of not merely avoiding telling altogether but finding the right mix of both techniques to engage readers effectively.
While many writers champion showing as the superior method for immersing readers in a narrative, there are instances where telling can enhance pacing and clarity, especially in intricate plots.
The Fallacy of Overtelling
A common criticism of writing advice is its propensity to promote overtelling, suggesting that writers must constantly showcase rather than explain. This perspective often assumes that novice writers begin with lengthy infodumps.
Consider a fictional scenario: "In 4062, the door opener was invented." This statement, while informative, may come across as overwhelming. The narrative dives into the history of door openers and their complex mechanics, which might not be necessary for establishing the context of a scene. Such oversimplified advice often misrepresents how new writers construct their stories.
This one-dimensional viewpoint overlooks the delicate balance between showing and telling, neglecting the unique requirements of different narratives. Some stories thrive on immersive, scene-driven storytelling, while others necessitate exposition to drive the plot or convey complex emotions.
The Paradox of Writing Advice
Despite the inherent limitations and subjectivity of writing advice, many writers actively seek input from experts and peers in their journey toward improvement. This pursuit isn't inherently negative. Recognizing the fallibility of advice and the existence of exceptions to every guideline allows us to glean valuable insights from seasoned writers.
Writing guidance acts as a navigational tool, offering foundational knowledge and techniques to refer to when uncertainty arises. As writers hone their skills through practice and exploration, they become more adept at determining when to adhere to specific advice and when to set it aside.
In the video titled "Why 'Show, Don't Tell' Is Bad Writing Advice," the creator explores the limitations of this popular writing maxim, emphasizing the importance of balance.
Chapter 2: Embracing Both Techniques
Incorporating both showing and telling in storytelling can lead to richer narratives. Each approach serves a distinct purpose, and understanding when to use one over the other can enhance a writer's craft.
In the video "The Most Common Writing Mistake: Why Telling And Exposition Are Actually Good," the discussion focuses on the necessity of telling in writing, revealing how it can complement showing and create a more coherent narrative.
As you navigate your writing journey, remember that both showing and telling hold value. Striking a balance between the two will ultimately lead to more compelling and engaging storytelling.