Chapter 1: The Estimation Dilemma

There are multiple factors contributing to the difficulty software developers face when estimating the duration of a project.

A recent interview I had for a freelance role highlighted this issue. The interviewer was a programmer, not an HR professional, which made for a more insightful discussion. He posed a key question: Why do programmers struggle with providing accurate estimates for software development projects? Drawing from my experience, I compiled a list of reasons that commonly contribute to this challenge.

One major reason is that developers often underestimate the time required for project completion. The larger the project becomes, the greater the discrepancy tends to be between the estimate and the actual time needed.

Developers frequently find themselves needing clarification when they attempt to give realistic assessments. To sidestep this issue, they might resort to overly optimistic estimates instead.

Another factor is that programmers often focus solely on the time required to write the code, neglecting other essential activities such as meetings, discussions with teammates, client interactions, code reviews, testing, debugging, and documentation. The cumulative time needed for these tasks can equal or even exceed the time spent on coding itself.

In extensive projects, uncertainty is often prevalent, especially in areas that are new to the team or dependent on ongoing developments by external partners. These uncertain areas must be evaluated separately, and a risk margin should be factored into the overall assessment.

Additionally, poorly defined functional specifications can complicate the estimation process. While detailed specifications are necessary, overly intricate details can lead to confusion and inefficiency.

Management sometimes harbors unrealistic expectations, failing to grasp that every intricate detail must be accurately translated into functional code. A lack of experience in software development among managerial staff can exacerbate this issue.

Software development is inherently a creative endeavor, with multiple potential solutions to any given problem. Numerous dependencies often remain unaddressed prior to project initiation, and the push for comprehensive planning often stems from a limited viewpoint on the part of the planners.

With experience, developers can refine their estimation skills by incorporating a safety margin based on intuition. Rigid thinking rarely proves beneficial in these scenarios.

In my own practice, I would list all necessary software modules and then enter a relaxed mindset to estimate the effort required for each module in person-days. After totaling these estimates, I would round them up to the nearest full man-week and confidently present the final figure.

More insights can be found at PlainEnglish.io. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter, and follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn. Join our community on Discord.